Teton Eats: Badger Creek Cafe

January 15, 2021

With its welcoming atmosphere, down-to-earth charm, and well-honed comfort foods, Tetonia’s Badger Creek Cafe feels like a decades-old community staple. You’d never know that the cafe is just four years old, a testament to the labor of owners Elyse Archer and John Flyg, who have worked tirelessly to make Badger Creek a pillar of Teton Valley.

Elyse and John moved to Tetonia from New York City in 2013. Their extensive culinary experience, including work in Michelin star-rated restaurants, secured them jobs at eateries in Tetonia, Victor and Jackson. But after several years in the community, the pair decided to take a risk and open their own restaurant. 

The result? “It went better than we ever could have expected,” enthuses Elyse.

The cafe was an immediate hit, winning over locals and tourists alike. And the source of the success was simple. “Good food is the most important part,” Elyse says. “We opened because we wanted to make affordable and delicious food.”

Elyse Archer and John Flyg pose with a hearty homemade feast prepared at their restaurant, Badger Creek Cafe. (Courtesy of Badger Creek Cafe)

The menu is a mix of time-honored classics — chicken and waffles, biscuits and gravy, corned beef hash — and inventive variety, such as the delectable fried chickpea fritters. John, who handles most of the cooking, prides himself on making things in-house and using as many locally-sourced ingredients as possible.

The personal touches show every time you sit down for a meal in the cafe. The Reuben — perhaps the very best in Teton Valley — comes with a pile of house corned beef, a handful of sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and a generous slathering of Thousand Island dressing. The Badger Burrito, meanwhile, has a delicious mixture of scrambled eggs, potatoes, peppers, onions, and cheese, with an option for scrumptious green chile pork. And no matter what you order, attentive and courteous service is a guarantee. 

Residents of Teton Valley have taken notice of what Elyse and John have achieved. Badger Creek has been voted the best breakfast in the valley for three years running, and the cafe enjoys a bevy of regulars, some of whom eat there upwards of three times a week.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

* indicates required

The restaurant has also charmed valley visitors. Elyse and John admit that the cafe’s unassuming appearance in a small town of under 300 can make it easy for people to miss. But those who do stop at Badger Creek frequently leave saying it is among the very best food the area has to offer.

“People often say they don’t expect much walking in here,” explains John. “They don’t expect it to look the way it does on the inside, let alone do they expect the food on the table.” 

Like many restaurant owners, Elyse and John did have to adapt their business in 2020 as a result of the coronavirus pandemic. Dine-in eating was temporarily suspended and hours of operation had to be adjusted. But with creative take-and-bake offerings as well as traditional takeout service, Badger Creek was able to stay open and connected to the community. Dine-in service has since resumed and the cafe is as vibrant as ever.

Life in the valley has allowed Elyse and John time to pursue other passions as well. John, a native of Pocatello, is an outdoorsman at heart, enjoying a wide variety of activities including fishing, hunting, snowmobiling, golfing and horseback riding. Elyse, meanwhile, discovered her love for roller derby after moving to the area, joining a team in the Jackson area.

But, for the owners, Badger Creek is their primary passion. “I love Tetonia, Tetonia is home,” says Elyse. “And being able to walk in, Dolly Parton is playing, drink some coffee — we just want it to be a rad, cool place.”


Badger Creek Cafe is located at 110 North Main Street in Tetonia, ID. It is open Thursday-Monday, 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.

See What Our Guests Are Saying!

This was a perfect launching spot for our group of…

Kali (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
July 16, 2021
This was a perfect launching spot for our group of 6 to explore the tetons. The kitchen had everything we needed. The beds and linen were super comfortable. The yard was great. We will definitely be back!Response:Kali - So happy you enjoyed your s...

Spotless place, plenty of space, hot tub is amazing, convenient…

Gage (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
March 14, 2021
Spotless place, plenty of space, hot tub is amazing, convenient location. Smoothest check in and check out I've had at an Airbnb. Jim the host was very responsive and provides instructions on how to use the hot tub, grill, etc. I highly recommend ...

It was the perfect place to stay

Jean C. (review from Vrbo)
5star rating
May 23, 2021
Wonderful property

We had a fantastic stay. I’m familiar with the area…

Robert (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
March 15, 2023
We had a fantastic stay. I’m familiar with the area and we got exactly what was described. I highly recommend!

We had a great time on our guys trip (4…

Andrew (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
May 22, 2022
We had a great time on our guys trip (4 people). Plenty of room, good amenities, and close proximity to town. Would recommend!

Great house

Edyta C. (review from Vrbo)
5star rating
July 27, 2022
Beautiful house with wonderful view, full stocked, very clean, very modern, perfect to relax, close to Teton.

Great space and location. Well equipped stay from kitchen supplies…

John (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
February 6, 2022
Great space and location. Well equipped stay from kitchen supplies to extra everything. We especially appreciated how our host was able to stage mother moose and calf three feet from front door. They seem to like the space as well.Response:Such a ...

The condo was amazing, clean and comfortable and the host…

Denise (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
July 24, 2022
The condo was amazing, clean and comfortable and the host also was a pleasure, will definitely stay here again!

Amazing!

Jason C. (review from Vrbo)
5star rating
December 28, 2022
Amazing property! My family had a wonderful time and this property felt like a home away from home. If you’re looking for a wonderful property for your vacation, you’re in the right place!

House was lovely. It is in a very nice neighborhood…

Tonya (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
October 4, 2021
House was lovely. It is in a very nice neighborhood a a perfect place to unwind after site seeing. Check in was so easy. Loved it so much I definitely will be back and will be letting my friends and family know this is were they need to stay.

The home was beautifully appointed. The full coffee and tea…

Scott (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
January 31, 2023
The home was beautifully appointed. The full coffee and tea bar was fantastic! The furniture was very comfortable. The additional game room in the garage was an excellent use of space with pin ball, air hockey and pop-a-shot. All three were used b...

The place was perfect for our visit to the Tetons….

Krishna (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
June 12, 2022
The place was perfect for our visit to the Tetons. It’s in a quiet neighborhood. The kitchen was huge. Everything was clean and stocked with essentials. Host was very responsive and fast to respond.

See What Our Guests Are Saying!

Perfect for extended ski vacation.

Andy S. (review from Vrbo)
5star rating
March 22, 2023
Very comfortable. Including the beds. Fully equipped with everything we needed. Very clean and in good condition.

We needed a propane tank for the grill and Jim…

Katey (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
March 26, 2023
We needed a propane tank for the grill and Jim was very quick to reply and got us one before we needed it!

Our stay here was wonderful and pleasant! The location is…

Amy (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
July 2, 2022
Our stay here was wonderful and pleasant! The location is close to town and we had access to a grocery store and gas station less than 10 minutes away! The scenery was gorgeous and I loved how close it was to Yellowstone. Not to mention that the A...

Such a great house! Lots of space and felt very…

Cara (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
September 19, 2021
Such a great house! Lots of space and felt very welcome with some small added touches from the host. Would absolutely recommend

The perfect place to stay. Very clean, new. Great water…

Dustin (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
September 1, 2021
The perfect place to stay. Very clean, new. Great water pressure. Large master closet. Bunk beds in the second room. Shares a driveway with 2 other buildings. Would stay again!

Jim was super accommodating and his response time was fast….

Talia (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
August 11, 2022
Jim was super accommodating and his response time was fast. His place is very spacious with plenty of room to relax and had enough bathrooms for a group of people. The neighborhood is quiet and beautiful! The location can’t be beat. We explored Ta...

Awesome location close to grand tetons. The condo is perfect….

Randy (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
July 14, 2022
Awesome location close to grand tetons. The condo is perfect. Will stay again if possible. Super convenient, clean and luxurious.

Great location! Communication with Jim was easy and the cabin…

Alida (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
July 28, 2022
Great location! Communication with Jim was easy and the cabin was well equipped and had a nice veranda. We loved staying there!

What a lovely condo! The location was perfect for our…

Tarra (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
January 1, 2022
What a lovely condo! The location was perfect for our ski week at the Grand Targhee. The bedrooms were spacious, the beds comfortable, and the place was quiet. Great kitchen and dining. Cozy fireplace and living area. Heated garage, which cam...

it’s such a cute stay!! for sure would want to…

Sara (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
April 18, 2021
it's such a cute stay!! for sure would want to stay here again!

Just as awesome as it looked! Exceptional in every way

Sean (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
April 6, 2021
Just as awesome as it looked! Exceptional in every way

Awesome home! Would definitely recommend.

Roger (review from Airbnb)
5star rating
September 3, 2022
Awesome home! Would definitely recommend.

© Wydaho Property Management LLC · All Rights Reserved .
Website by Hudson Creative Studio Hudson Creative Studio.